The New York Giants have opened their wallets across nearly every position group, hoping to finally escape the endless cycle of rebuilding.
They’ve shelled out for defensive upgrades, brought in two veteran QBs, and spent a first-round pick on Jaxson Dart to inject new life into the offense.
But despite all the moves, their offensive line still feels like the team’s most fragile weak point—with everything riding on the health of one man: Andrew Thomas.
Andrew Thomas: The Foundation With Cracks
Thomas is not only the team’s best offensive lineman—he might be the most important player on the entire roster. The Giants clearly agree, rewarding him with a massive five-year, $117.5 million extension, which officially kicks in this season and carries a $21 million cap hit.
But for all his talent, his durability remains a major red flag.
Last season, Thomas managed just 416 snaps while battling nagging injuries that never fully healed. He allowed 16 pressures and four sacks in that limited action. Over the last two years, he hasn’t even reached 600 snaps in a season—a serious issue for a player tasked with protecting the blind side of a brand-new quarterback.
Andrew Thomas injury update: Giants All-Pro left tackle has surgery on ailing foot, out for rest of season – CBSSports.com
Andrew Thomas
Little Depth Behind the Big Investment
In many ways, the Giants’ reliance on Thomas feels like building on unstable ground. They’re hoping he stays upright, because behind him, the depth chart is filled with question marks—young, unproven players who haven’t shown they can handle starting duties if called upon.
With a rookie QB potentially seeing action in 2025, the lack of experienced protection on the left side is a huge gamble.
The Good News? Thomas Is Finally Healthy
There is a silver lining: Thomas is entering the new season in his best shape in years. After taking the offseason to fully recover and rebuild strength in his lower body, he’s poised for a bounce-back year.
When fully healthy, he’s among the NFL’s elite left tackles—able to neutralize top pass rushers and bring stability to the entire offense.
But given his recent injury history, every hit, every awkward fall, and every time he grabs at a leg will leave Giants fans holding their breath.